Have you tried Edward’s latest?
Here it is swatched, on me it pulls very warm:
The shades in Pale Nude include a frosted cool white, a yellowish light cream with an iridescent sheen, a soft nude pink shimmer and a warm tan beige shimmer. All the colors in this palette have shimmer and frost. The color payoff is excellent like Pale Barley but not quite as metallic on the lids making this a great everyday staple. Texture is buttery smooth like the Burberry singles. I found the texture of this quad to be the best out of all the ones I tested.
A few comparisons to other shades:
- Pale Nude’s white is not as sharp as Porcelain White, but very similar
- Pale Nude’s yellow cream looked similar to Porcelain in the compact, but it’s quite a bit more yellow
- Pale Nude’s seashell pink is more neutral/warm than other Burberry pinks, I found it similar to Chanel’s Sillage single, just more neutral
- Pale Nude’s brown shimmer is warmer and darker than Pale Barley
- a warm yellow cream shimmer – smooth and buttery like most Burberry single shadows, great for a blending color
- a warm shimmery sienna, soft texture, easy to apply but not so easy to blend (needs a more precise application)
- a dark chocolate brown with gold flecks of shimmer, great pigment, but also harder texture like NARS Galapagos makes it not so easy to blend/smoke out
- a satiny dark black, soft texture rich pigment, blends well
- a soft matte ivory that matches my skintone when applied, very similar to Trench but a tad warmer
- a warm golden beige-tan with subtle shimmer, nearly identical to Gold Trench
- a warm matte chestnut brown, lighter than Chestnut
- a warm bronze shimmer, unique compared to other browns from Burberry, but still very basic
Did you try or buy Mocha? What were your thoughts?
Update, here is another swatch set under artificial light, I don’t know why the matte grey goes on so warm on my skin. On the eyes it’s more true to what you see in the pan:
- I didn’t test all the Armani quads, but based on the two that I have, I feel the Burberry has a softer more buttery/blendable texture but more pigmented payoff in color. The Armani Maestro 01 seems to be cooler-toned and more subtle judging from swatches on Fruity Lashes, Beautezine and Best Things in Beauty.
- Chanel Smokey Eyes is a quad I used to have (but think I gifted it away). It’s a quad that was extremely high maintenance and often clashed with the yellow tones in my skin. I think the Burberry has more buildable pigment (from what I remember). The Chanel appears to be cooler-toned as well. Cafe Makeup has excellent photos and swatches.
- Compared to the Burberry single shadows, I found the texture and pigment similar. This particular quad was slightly more powdery, but I didn’t experience any fallout when I applied it on the lids. For color similarities, the white is very similar to Pearl White, but not as blue as Porcelain White. The gunmetal metallic shimmer is more pigmented and deeper than Pearl Grey. The black shade has better pigment than Midnight Black. You can probably achieve the same effect and don’t need the quad if you have the singles.
Comparisons to Pearl White, Pearl Grey, Midnight Black and Edward Bess’s Soft Smoke Trio (which is my favorite smokey eye palette).
- Temptalia has a gorgeous tutorial
- Makeup and Beauty Blog has some preview photos
- Best Things in Beauty has pigmented swatches
- Natural N Chic Makeup has swatches of the Europe/Asia version
shimmery side but not quite as sparkly as Intuition. It has a
cool-toned powdery pink satin, a silvery sage metallic, a warm brown and
an eggplant shimmer. I thought this would be my favorite out of the
two, but it’s borderline too cool for my skin. It’s still quite lovely
on olive complexion but I prefer Mystic Eyes to this one. I haven’t seen the European/baked version of Variation in person, but judging from online reviews/swatches, I think I prefer the color payoff of the Euro one better. Some other swatches to check out:
- Café Makeup swatched and reviewed the European baked version earlier this year
- Kosmetista has the baked version swatched with an eye look
- Temptalia has a helpful tutorial for inspiration
- Best Things in Beauty has a great review
For me Intuition was a lovely surprise. It looked like it would be too neutral or unoriginal but it really is quite lovely. Variation on the other hand was a slight disappointment. The colors are really lovely but needs a bit of warming up for my skintone.
Have you spotted the Les Expressions de Chanel collection yet? I’m still waiting to see the whole collection, but at this time think I will probably pass on everything else. Perhaps I will consider the mascara?